Are we all happy with Mike Shehans top 50 list?

Im pretty happy with it, that guy knows his stuff.

Yeah i had a quick look at it, the top 5 was ok, but how does cooney who won the brownlow not make the top 5, also (Yes i'm biased) Richo gets beat by a couple of votes and rates 15th.

People are always going to disagree on the top 50, really i just glanced over it, as it's only Mike Sheehan rating them, some spaz who has never pulled on boot in anger.

You'd think Hille would be inside the top 50, like i said it's only Sheehans opinion.

In all reality, who the hell is Mike Sheahan ! Why are people so easily led like a dog on a chain. Mike Sheahan is a goose (with all respect to that animal) Let me consider a ' top 50 ' list from Tom Hafey ,Ron Barassi, Kevin Sheedy, Bobby Skilton, Alex Jesualenko, Allan Jeans, James Hird, or Nathan Buckley real football " people" who have actually 'competed' on the MCG, and KNOW and respect what really is required of a player to succeed in the game .

No-one's top 50 predictions for 2009 are going to be the same (or even close) and Sheehan is giving his own opinion not a general consensus of the entire football watching public. There's always going to be some inclusions/exclusions/placements that will create debate - in fact that's what Sheehan would be trying to achieve.

Mmm.

Those 5 would form the nucleus of a top side: a small forward, a centreman, full forward, ruck and on-baller.

What was Sheehan's highest ranked defender?

Is there a link to see the full fifty?

Can't really comment unless I see the whole list.

1. Ablett

2. Franklin

3. Judd

4. Cooney

5. Bartel

I hate Mike Shehan's reporting and his stupid lists. I always ignore his writing.

0 melbourne players

huuuuhhhh no one gives a crap about my dees. well fuk u

The likes of brad green or cam bruce should have been in the top 50 at least?

Otherwise then that was ok and its pretty obvious that ablett #1

Gotta agree with Romper, its one man's (spaz) opinion and yet the media goes by that list.

For crying out loud.......the man hasn't even played senior footy and yet he he gives his opinions and writes his stories as if its gospel.

The man is a joke.......and is a **** stirrer.

Judd is top ten not top 2, its one man's opinion and of course their will be disagreements

The guy has no clue.

No Daniel Cross. Is he for real?